The Best Cat Toys of 2019: Safety Tips, Reviews, and More!

Reading Time: 3 minutes

image of the best cat toys and cat chew toys

All kittens need physical and mental stimulation to be healthy. In nature, cats spend their days chasing birds and mice. Even indoor cats have natural instincts that tell them to be active. So, getting cat toys for your four-legged feline friend is an awesome idea. They’re not only a ton of fun for Mittens but they also keep their physical and mental wellbeing in check!

From Cute Plushies to Cat Chew Toys: Cats Need Cat Stuff!

All pet owners know cats can be very low maintenance. Yet, this doesn’t mean they don’t need cat stuff! You probably already have the must-have cat bed and the miracle cat scratcher. But have you ever thought that cats need cat toys?

We recommend getting things to keep your cat entertained, especially if they are indoor cats! You certainly don’t want your feline friend getting frustrated. Otherwise, you can say goodbye to your carpet, couch, and you’ll come home to a mess of ruined toilet paper.

Ultimately, cat toys keep boredom at bay. Trust us, getting Mittens a plush toy or a chew toy is a great choice for you and for them!

Safety First: 5 Things to Consider When Choosing the Best Cat Toys for Mittens

Not all cat toys are made equal. There are some things you need to be on the lookout for. When shopping for your next play toy, keep these recommendations in mind:

  1. Avoid loose yarn, ribbon, and strings: Cats can easily choke on the fabric fibers that make up these pieces.
  2. Stay away from plastic bags: It’s easy for a cat to become so excited with a plastic bag that they get it around their head and suffocate.
  3. Leave small toys alone: Kittens love to put toys in their mouth, but if they’re too small, there’s a chance they might choke on them.
  4. Rubber bands and paper clips are a no-no: Kitties can suffocate while trying to swallow these toys. Alternatively, if they do swallow them, they can hurt their GI tract.
  5. Anything with glue is to be avoided: You shouldn’t get toys that have exposed glue; the adhesive has harmful chemicals that may poison a curious cat.

Looking for the Best Interactive Cat Toys?

Interactive cat toys are a ton of fun. They simulate your kitten both mentally and physically! The Petstages Tower of Tracks is one of the best out there. It has three balls in three different stages and non-skid pads at the bottom. The icing on the cake is that your kitty will never again lose their ball toy under the couch.

Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy
Your kitty will never lose another ball under the couch with the Petstages Tower of Tracks Cat Toy. With three exciting levels, this interactive toy encourages extended playtime as the colorful balls spin and roll around and around. It’s great for multiple-cat households and independent play because it lets cats enjoy an action-packed afternoon even when you’re not at home. The stacked play station is built to last and features non-skid pads so it won’t move about as your kitty plays.
Rated 4.50/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on Chewy!


kitten playing with interactive cat toys

Your Kitty Will Love Jackson Galaxy Cat Toys!

No one knows more about feline behavior than Jackson Galaxy. You can now get the wand toy he gives cats to play with on his show! The Mojo Maker Air Prey is perfect in the fight against boredom, it burns off extra calories, and keeps those natural instincts sharp.

Jackson Galaxy Mojo Maker Air Prey Laser Wand Teaser
Enjoy two-in-one fun with the Jackson Galaxy Air Prey Removable Laser Wand Teaser Cat Toy. Allowing you to engage your cat’s raw instincts, it features a laser that your cat will love to hunt. And when he’s ready for a new thrill, switch to swatting and batting at the feather toy—he’ll think it’s a bird flying through the air, and the satisfaction of a “catch” is great for his confidence. The telescoping wand can be made longer or shorter so that you direct the play, and the retractable cord prevents tangles so the fun never gets interrupted.
Rated 4.00/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on Chewy!

Mix Things Up With a Glow Worm Toy or LED Balls!

Play time is always a lot more fun when lights are involved. The Spiral Galaxy LED Balls keep even the least active pets engaged and entertained. Simply shake these electronic cat toy balls, roll them on the floor, and watch as Mittens sprints after it!

Jackson Galaxy Spiral Galaxy LED Balls
The Jackson Galaxy Spiral Galaxy LED Balls Cat Toy provides your kitty with hours of interactive fun. As your cat bats them around, these brightly colored balls light up to keep her interested in playtime. The Spiral Galaxy LED Balls ensure an afternoon filled with chasing and pouncing as your cat engages her natural hunting instincts to trap them.
Rated 4.00/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on Chewy!

Other Cat Supplies and Cat Products That Are a Must for Mittens!

Besides cat toys, there are other cat essentials you need to have if you’re welcoming a kitty into your life.

For starters, a comfortable cat bed is a great investment. Secondly, getting high-quality cat litter is super important to keep your home clean and odor-free. Thirdly, safe and clean cat water fountains are also needed. Fourthly, you need a cat scratching pole or tree for Mittens for them to keep their claws sharp and healthy.

Lastly, CBD oil does wonders for kittens with anxiety and chronic physical conditions!

Help your feline companion overcome the challenges life throws their way and get back to making long-lasting memories with them all for less than $2 a day - that's less than a cup of coffee! With the help of our 100% Full Spectrum CBD OIL, straight from the sun-grown Colorado hemp farms.
Rated 5.00/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on

Up for a Game of Cat and Mouse?

What better way to bring fun into your cat’s life than by letting them play with the SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Toy? This mouse cat toy is perfect for any occasion. Cats and kittens of all ages love to play with them. Plus, the catnip on the inside is an awesome bonus!

SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Toy
The SmartyKat Skitter Critters Catnip Cat Toy has a kitty’s three favorite things – mice, strings and catnip. This furry mouse toy has a soft texture that feels good to a cat’s teeth and claws and a twisted rope tail for chasing. Every cat needs a good mouse toy to bite, kick and carry around. SmartyKat’s Skitter Critters are safe for pets and spiked with potent catnip to spark the fun. This pack comes with three mice in case some get lost under the sofa.
Rated 3.50/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on Chewy!

Sometimes the Best Toys Are Simple Toys!

There are times when less is more, and that applies to cat toys, too! The Ethical Pet Durable Spring Cat Toy is a hit with all pets. They love chasing around this bouncy spring. Besides being a ton of fun, this toy also encourages your cat to get exercised without even realizing it.

Ethical Pet Wide Durable Heavy Gauge Plastic Colorful Springs Cat Toy
Put a little "spring" in your cat's step with these colorful, bouncy, plastic spring cat toys. Your cat will have fun chasing them around while their unpredictable bounce will drive them nuts! Great toy to entertain your ferret too!
Rated 4.00/5.00 by Certapet
Buy on Chewy!


kitten playing with blue ball cat toy

DIY Cat Toys: Why Not Try Your Hand at Some Homemade Cat Toys?

The most meaningful gifts come from the heart, right? So, making homemade cat toys is bound to be a success. Cats don’t need much when it comes to play things. A fishing pole toy, a plush mouse toy, or a cardboard scratcher are big hits!

As long as the DIY toy is bouncy, flashy, and moves a lot in unexpected ways, they’ll love it! Just keep the safety tips in mind.

A Cat Toy Can Be as Simple as a Cardboard Box or Crinkle Paper!

More often than not, cats love to play with the most unexpected things. When was the last time you had a cardboard box at home they didn’t want to play in?

As you can see, you can make Kitty’s life better while also on a budget. A cardboard box and crinkle paper go a long way!

Crochet Cat Toys

If you’re handy with a crochet needle, then making your kitten a crochet cat toy is an awesome idea! There are dozens of free patterns online you can follow. All you’ll need is some crochet yarn and that is it. You can also stuff it with catnip to make it all the more fun for Mittens.

kitten with fluffy diy cat toys

Just Add Some Catnip and You’ll Be Good to Go!

Cats go crazy for catnip — in a good way. They love the smell of it, so it’s no surprise that catnip cat toys are their favorite! You can even add catnip to your kitten’s preferred toy. It’s a great way to reinvent long-loved and long-forgotten toys.

Common Questions on Cat Toys

Are all cat toys safe for kittens?

What cat toy will challenge my kitty mentally?

What’s the best budget-friendly cat toy?

All product and Company names are Trademarks™ or Registered® trademarks of their respective holders.

Disclosure: Bear in mind that some of the links in this post are affiliate links and if you go through them to make a purchase may earn a commission. Keep in mind that we link these companies and their products because of their quality and not because of the commission we receive from your purchases. The decision is yours, and whether or not you decide to buy something is completely up to you.